Skip to main content

When the Stars Line Up

From 2010 to 2011, Alex Smith gained one receiver, Braylon Edwards. The 49ers backfield gained rookie Kendall Hunter, and the defense acquired rookie linebacker Aldon Smith. There have been some other changes to the 49er roster, but can these fairly insignificant pickups really account for a 9-1 record in week 10, after going 6-10 last year and missing the playoffs in the lowly NFC West? The real change, although it is hard to prove, is coach Jim Harbaugh.

Initially, I will note, that other than play calling and technique, I find very little sympathy for people who argue that coaches really make a significant difference in the NFL. And I know that I'll get shit for saying that, but let it go for the time being. After all, one can hardly call Harbaugh a revolutionary college coach, after he basically one the lottery with Andrew Luck and Toby Gerhart leading the Cardinal offense. So for now, imagine Jim Harbaugh has not really accomplished anything.

So what makes him such a great coach? It's certainly not his transition from college to the NFL. If we look historically, the average successful college coach has very little success in the NFL. Nick Saban, the captain of the Roll Tide brigade, failed conclusively to coach another seafaring bunch during his stint with the Dolphins (2 Alabama National Championships, compared to a 15-17 overall record with the Dolphins).

And Saban certainly isn't the only unsuccessful college coach who tried their luck in the NFL. Bobby Petrino, Steve Spurrier, and Lou Holtz, lead a long list of NFL failures.

So obviously, Harbaugh's success cannot be accredited to his college accomplishments.


The next logical fact about Harbaugh to examine would be his relation to John Harbaugh, his brother, and the head coach of the Ravens. But once again, we find that NFL lineage, historically, does little for a coach's success.

For example, Monte Kiffin, the "father of the 'Tampa 2' defense", is widely considered one of the best defensive coordinators in NFL history, yet his son Lane went 5-15 in 1+ seasons as the head coach of the Raiders.

Or what about Kyle Shanahan, son of Mike Shanahan. While his father is an extremely glorified NFL coach, Kyle has bounced around as a coordinator despite being the youngest offensive coordinator ever.

Thus, it seems that Harbaugh's success really cannot be accredited to lineage or coaching history. But maybe, it's the combination of both that has resulted in his success. Somehow, the combination of previous coaching career and lineage to another NFL coach has resulted in a 9-1 record and a lead in the NFC West. It truly seems the stars have aligned for Harbaugh, and as much as it pains me to admit it (being an avid Raiders fan), the 49ers are a force to be reckoned with in the NFL this year.

And if you're still not convinced that I'm right about Harbaugh, maybe it's his tenacity and ferocity that have made him successful:
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Let's Start it Up

The original inspiration for this blog was my cousin, a man who himself, during college, wrote a blog about sports. However, unlike the analytical master I have proven to be during my tenure as a blogger, he relied, perhaps to better results, on his wit and vulgarity. This lead, unfortunately, to his inability to continue his blogging career, once he got a stable job, and had a necessity for a clean image. When I began my writing, I had a similar dilemma, as I hoped my blog would look good on college applications, and thus was unable to use much vulgar language. Well now that that whole process is over, I'd like to welcome you all back, and get some things of my chest: Fuck those motherfucking Detroit Tigers , you goddamn abusers of the MLB system. A team should get like a 1-0 lead in a series for having a regular season record 10 games better than the other team. Because my Oakland A's were more than fucking deserving of an ALCS birth this year. So Justin Verlander can s...
1 comment
Read more

The Art of The Draft

Whenever I ramble to my peers about NFL prospect Cam Newton , whether it be his scrutinized college career, or his remarkable climb to the top, the most common response I receive is "Why don't you just suck his.....(ya know)". Anyway, after I wittily respond with "present it", I come back from the world of soccer , and try to re-evaluate the current Heisman Trophy Winner. Yet, no matter which way I look at it, what Mr. Newton has accomplished over the past year is remarkable. And I believe there are 32 NFL GM's who have thought exactly the same thing. The only difference is that if I think Newton is good, the worst it can do is hurt my fantasy team, whereas it could cost a team millions of dollars to invest in the Auburn Quarterback. And the same situation exists across the board for this years crop of Quarterback prospects, and for all draftees for that matter. But I'll leave the cross-examination of corners and offensive linemen to the owners, and fo...
2 comments
Read more

Brett Favre's Illustrious Career and 'The Viking Situation'

Seeing as this is my first post, I would like to ask for a pass in advance for any typos, or errors in my facts in any of my posts. As his career comes to an end, (hopefully) I would like to take this time to examine Brett Favre 's career and my self-entitled 'Viking Situation' , and relate it to Any Given Sunday , which seemingly hasn't been done (other than this and this , both of which fail to fully relate 'The Viking Situation'), which I believe is odd. As well, as a disclaimer, I realize that the movie does not model the current situation, given the time difference, and merely wish to offer an odd amount of similarities. Brett Favre Dennis Quaid First, and most prevalently, credit must be given where credit is due. Brett Favre is arguably one of the best quarterbacks of all time, and seemingly the toughest. His record for yards (71,838) and touchdowns (508) are hard to argue with, although he also holds the records for most times sacked and most...
Post a Comment
Read more